mark-elliott.net

Heylighen discusses the role of stigmergy and the open access economy.

Francis Heylighen’s recent work Why is Open Access Development so Successful? Stigmergic organization and the economics of information presents a straight forward and compelling case for stigmergy as an underlying mechanism in the expansion of what he terms, ‘open access development’.
Heylighen provides three characteristics in order to designate information as “open access”. The information must be:

• non-proprietary,
• part of a creative commons free to access, use, and in many cases modify, and
• consisting purely of information that can be duplicated without limit.

Recognising the inherent connections between stigmergy and the workings of the World Wide Web, Heylighen reviews the basic process:

…termites do not communicate about who is to do what how or when. Their only communication is indirect: the partially executed work of the ones provides information to the others about where to make their own contribution. In this way, there is no need for a centrally controlled plan, workflow, or division of labor.

and connects it to Internet-based processes:

…any new or revised document or software component uploaded to the site of a community is immediately scrutinized by the members of the community that are interested to use it. When one of them discovers a shortcoming, such as a bug, error or lacking functionality, that member will be inclined to either solve the problem him/herself, or at least point it out to the rest of the community, where it may again entice someone else to take up the problem.

Heylighen draws on the autocatalyitc nature of stigmergy to explain the success of various projects in the open access domain (Wikipedia, Open Source Software etc) by recognising that

…the more high quality material is already available on the community site, the more people will be drawn to check it out, and thus the more people are available to improve it further. Thus, open access can profit from a positive feedback cycle that boosts successful projects.

However he also notes that

A possible disadvantage of such “rich get richer” dynamics is that equally valuable, competing projects, because of random fluctuations or sequence effects, may fail to get the critical mass necessary to “take off”.

Finally, Heylighen recommends:

To be able to fully compete with the established market-based system, moreover, the still very young open access movement will need to further learn from its experiences, addressing its remaining weaknesses and building further on its strengths. This will in particular require developing better standards and rules, and more powerful software solutions for harnessing stigmergy and allocating recognition and feedback—the main drivers behind the success of open access according to the present analysis.

In all, Heylighen provides a sound introduction to stigmergy and its relationship to the recent development of peer production / open access, which I hope will serve to generate interest and research into the role of stigmergic coordination of human affairs.

–Oh, and he cites my work Stigmergic Collaboration: The Evolution of Group Work… which is cool ;-).

---

More media, more interactive, more collaborative, more stigmergic.

Stigmergic collaboration seems set to really take off with the advent of AJAX programming methods – Thinkature.com is a great example of this.

I was able to draw, create stickies-like notes, connect them mindmappishly, do an image search either online or on my computer within the workspace window and just drag and drop it in. And of course the best thing (although i haven’t tested it yet so I can’t vouch for its capacities) is that the workspaces are synchronous collaboration environments supporting chat and even voice chat.

I’d really like to see support for embedding sound, video, and well, why stop there, let’s have video chat as well!

ConceptShare.com looks nifty too but I haven’t had a chance to play with it yet…

---

First smiles caught on video.

They’ve been smiling for months now, but it is getting much more frequent so we decided to try to catch it on video. Of course, i had to whip something up in imovie – it’s short but cute. The background sound gives you a good idea what lengths we will go to to get a smile… it’s so fun!

Here’s a few more pix, this time from Mom’s – that is Sherry’s Flickr account:

Cedar!

Lucas!

In my next instalment, i’ll give a rundown of the trials and tribulations with our house renovations – we’re moved in, but still moving.. if that makes sense…